Product Data and Sample Submittals: Review Criteria, Conformance Verification, Distribution, and Record Keeping

How the architect reviews product data and physical sample submittals for design conformance, the contractor's verification obligations before submission, distribution protocols, and documentation requirements for maintaining submittal records.

ARE · Construction & Evaluation

Overview

Product data and samples are two of the three primary submittal types (alongside shop drawings) that contractors must provide before installing specified materials and equipment. Product data consists of manufacturer's literature: catalog sheets, performance charts, installation instructions, material safety data sheets, and test reports that describe a product's characteristics. Samples are physical specimens of materials, finishes, or equipment components that demonstrate actual color, texture, pattern, and quality.

The contractor is required to review and verify product data and samples for compliance with the contract documents before transmitting them to the architect. Under A201 Section 3.12.6, the contractor's submission represents that the contractor has reviewed and approved the submittal, determined and verified relevant materials and field measurements, and checked and coordinated the information with the requirements of the work.

The architect reviews these submittals for the limited purpose of checking conformance with the design concept and information in the contract documents. The review is not intended to determine accuracy and completeness, nor does it constitute approval of safety precautions or construction means and methods. This limited scope protects the architect while placing the verification burden where it belongs: on the contractor.

Product data and samples flow through a defined distribution chain. The contractor submits to the architect, the architect reviews and returns marked copies, and the contractor distributes approved submittals to affected subcontractors and suppliers. Maintaining records of all submittals, review actions, and distribution is part of the architect's construction administration responsibility.

Essential

What Counts as Product Data Product data encompasses all printed or electronic information furnished by manufacturers to describe their products. This includes: - Catalog sheets showing product dimensions, materials, and available options - Performance data including load capacities, thermal values, fire ratings, and acoustic ratings - Installation instructions from the manufacturer - Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS/SDS) for hazardous materials - Test reports from independent laboratories (UL listings, FM approvals, ASTM test results) - Warranty information and maintenance requirements - Sustainability documentation (recycled content, VOC emissions, LEED credit data) Product data is typically standard manufacturer's literature, not custom-prepared for the project. The contractor highlights or marks the specific model, size, color, and options being proposed for the project. This marking is critical because a catalog page may show dozens of options. Without the contractor's markings, the architect cannot determine which specific product is being submitted.

Professional

The limited scope of the architect's submittal review under A201 Section 4.2.7 is both a protection and a trap. The protection is clear: by reviewing only for design conformance, the architect avoids assuming responsibility for the contractor's work. The trap is that architects sometimes review beyond their required scope, inadvertently expanding their liability. When an architect marks up product data with detailed comments about installation methods, correct fastener sizes, or field conditions, those comments may be interpreted as direction regarding means and methods. If a problem later arises from the installation, the contractor may argue that the architect assumed responsibility by directing the work. The professional practice risk here is real: keep review comments focused on design conformance and avoid directing construction means and methods.

TLDR

Product data is manufacturer's literature (catalogs, test reports, performance charts). Samples are physical material specimens. The contractor must review both for specification compliance before submitting to the architect (A201 Sections 3.12.5-3.12.6). The architect reviews for design conformance only (A201 Section 4.2.7), not accuracy, completeness, or means and methods. Review actions: Approved, Approved as Noted, Revise and Resubmit, or Rejected. No work proceeds until the submittal is reviewed. Keep records of everything.

ELI5

Imagine you are planning a birthday party and you hire someone to decorate. Before they start, you want to see what decorations they plan to use. They show you a catalog page with the balloons they picked and bring you a real balloon to feel the quality and see the actual color. The catalog page is like product data. The real balloon is like a sample. In construction, the contractor has to show the architect what materials they want to use before they install them. The contractor sends catalog pages from manufacturers (product data) and actual pieces of materials like tile, brick, or paint chips (samples). But here is the important part: before the contractor sends anything to the architect, the contractor has to check it first. The contractor has to make sure the catalog page matches what the specification says.

Overview

Essential

What Counts as Product Data Product data encompasses all printed or electronic information furnished by manufacturers to describe their products. This includes: - Catalog sheets showing product dimensions, materials, and available options - Performance data including load capacities, thermal values, fire ratings, and acoustic ratings - Installation instructions from the manufacturer - Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS/SDS) for hazardous materials - Test reports from independent laboratories (UL listings, FM approvals, ASTM test results) - Warranty information and maintenance requirements - Sustainability documentation (recycled content, VOC emissions, LEED credit data) Product data is typically standard manufacturer's literature, not custom-prepared for the project. The contractor highlights or marks the specific model, size, color, and options being proposed for the project. This marking is critical because a catalog page may show dozens of options. Without the contractor's markings, the architect cannot determine which specific product is being submitted.

Professional

TLDR

ELI5

AREConstruction & Evaluation

Product Data and Sample Submittals: Review Criteria, Conformance Verification, Distribution, and Record Keeping

2 min read241 words

Product Data and Samples: The Submittals That Show What Gets Built

Want to track your progress and access more study tools?

Create a free account