Qualifications-Based Selection (QBS) and the Brooks Act

How federal and state governments select architects and engineers based on qualifications rather than price, the legal framework of the Brooks Act, the QBS process from public announcement through fee negotiation, and why this matters for architectural practice.

ARE · Practice Management

Overview

When the federal government needs an architect or engineer, it doesn't just pick the cheapest option. It picks the most qualified one. That's been the law since 1972, when Congress passed the Brooks Act (Public Law 92-582).

The Brooks Act created a procurement method called Qualifications-Based Selection, or QBS. Under QBS, government agencies evaluate firms based on their competence, experience, and professional qualifications. Price doesn't enter the conversation until after the top firm has been chosen. Only then do the agency and firm sit down to negotiate a fee that's fair and reasonable.

This matters for your career and for the ARE. The QBS framework shapes how architectural firms pursue public-sector work, how they prepare SF330 qualification statements, and how they structure their business development efforts. Roughly 47 states have adopted their own versions of the Brooks Act, often called "mini-Brooks acts," so QBS isn't just a federal concept. It drives procurement at the state and local level too.

For the PcM exam, you need to understand the QBS process from start to finish: the public announcement, the qualifications evaluation, the shortlisting of at least three firms, the sequential negotiation procedure, and the rationale for separating qualifications from price. You also need to know when QBS applies and when it doesn't.

Essential

The Brooks Act isn't just some dusty federal regulation. It's the reason architectural firms compete on talent instead of price for government work. Understanding this law and the QBS process it mandates is critical for PcM, and it directly affects how firms operate, market themselves, and win public-sector projects. ## The Brooks Act: Origin and Purpose Congress passed the Brooks Act (Public Law 92-582) on October 27, 1972. The law is codified at 40 U.S.C. Sections 1101-1104. Its core declaration is simple: the federal government must negotiate contracts for architectural and engineering services on the basis of demonstrated competence and qualification, not price. Section 902 of the Act states that federal policy requires public announcement of all requirements for A/E services and negotiation of contracts based on demonstrated competence and qualification at fair and reasonable prices. Notice the sequence there. Competence first. Price second.

Professional

Consider a mid-size architecture firm preparing to pursue a new federal courthouse project managed by GSA. The project will be procured through QBS under the Brooks Act. No pricing information can influence selection. The firm's entire strategy revolves around demonstrating qualifications. The firm's marketing director monitors government solicitations and identifies the project announcement. The team conducts a go/no-go analysis, assessing whether the firm's courthouse experience, available key personnel, and geographic reach match the solicitation criteria. Since the solicitation includes a local office presence criterion weighted at 8% of the total evaluation, the firm considers whether to commit to a local project office near the courthouse site. The firm assembles its SF330 submission. Part I targets this specific project: relevant courthouse and federal building experience, proposed key personnel with their professional registrations and project histories, and a project approach narrative.

TLDR

The Brooks Act (Public Law 92-582, 1972) requires federal agencies to select A/E firms based on qualifications, not price. Price negotiation happens only after selecting the most qualified firm.
The QBS process: public announcement, qualifications evaluation (no price), shortlist of at least 3 firms, sequential negotiation starting with #1 ranked.
If negotiation fails with the top firm, the agency formally terminates and moves to #2. No simultaneous negotiations allowed.
Price, in-state preference, and cost-related data are all prohibited as evaluation criteria. Local office presence is allowed but capped at 10% of total evaluation weight.
The 6% statutory cap (FAR Part 15.404) limits design deliverable fees to 6% of estimated construction cost on public works. This doesn't cover all professional services.
Roughly 47 states have "mini-Brooks acts" requiring QBS for state-funded A/E work. Scope varies by state.
The SF330 form (Part I: project-specific; Part II: general firm qualifications on file) is the standard federal submission for QBS.
QBS is required for FAHP-funded engineering services tied to a construction project. Planning studies without a construction connection generally don't require it.
For IPD and collaborative delivery, QBS is considered the most compatible procurement method.

ELI5

Imagine you need surgery. Would you pick a surgeon based on who charges the least? Probably not. You'd want the most skilled, most experienced one you can find. Then you'd talk about what it costs. That's exactly how the government picks architects and engineers. There's a law called the Brooks Act that says: when the federal government needs a building designed or a bridge engineered, it has to pick the firm that's most qualified for the job. Price doesn't get discussed until after they've already decided who's best. Here's how the process works. First, the government puts out a public announcement saying, "We need an architect for this project." Firms send in their qualifications, kind of like a really detailed resume for the company. The government reviews all these submissions, talks to at least three firms, and then ranks the top three (or more) based purely on who's most qualified.

AREPractice Management

Qualifications-Based Selection (QBS) and the Brooks Act

2 min read211 words

Why Architects Aren't Selected by Lowest Bid

Want to track your progress and access more study tools?

Create a free account